High-speed PCB design is critical in the development of modern electronic products, as it involves the transfer of high-speed digital data between processors, components, and modules. This type of design is essential for products incorporating digital processors, often microcontrollers running embedded software. However, designing for high-speed signals presents unique challenges due to the broad bandwidth and frequency range of these signals, which theoretically extend to infinity.

Signal integrity issues such as distortion and reflections can plague high-speed designs if not managed properly. Additionally, power integrity problems like switching noise, ground bounce, and high Power Distribution Network (PDN) impedance are common in high-speed circuits. These challenges necessitate a thorough understanding of the high-speed signal frequency range and careful consideration of PCB stackup design to ensure controlled impedance and proper signal behavior.

The purpose of this article is to guide you through the process of selecting the right PCB design software for your high-speed PCB project, addressing these challenges and ensuring a successful design outcome.

Understanding High-Speed PCB Design

High-speed PCB design involves creating circuit boards that can handle the rapid transfer of digital data between processors, components, and modules. This type of design is crucial for products with digital processors, often microcontrollers running embedded software. High-speed signals have a broad bandwidth, theoretically extending to infinity, which requires careful design considerations to ensure proper signal behavior.

Key considerations in high-speed PCB design include:

• Signal Integrity: High-speed designs can suffer from signal integrity issues such as distortion and reflections if not designed properly. Signal integrity problems arise from the broad bandwidth of high-speed signals and require precise management of trace geometry and PCB stackup.
• Power Integrity: Power integrity is another critical aspect, as high-speed designs are prone to switching noise, ground bounce, and high Power Distribution Network (PDN) impedance. Ensuring adjacent power and ground planes in the PCB stackup can provide high interplane capacitance, improving power integrity.
• PCB Stackup Design: The stackup design significantly impacts both signal and power integrity. It determines the trace geometry required for controlled impedance and must account for variations in the dielectric constant of the PCB transmission line across the entire signal bandwidth.
• Controlled Impedance: Proper impedance control is essential for maintaining signal integrity in high-speed designs. This involves careful calculation and design of trace geometries and PCB stackup to match the impedance requirements of high-speed signals.

Understanding these key considerations is essential for designing high-speed PCBs that function correctly and reliably in their intended applications.

Key Features to Look for in PCB Design Software

Selecting the right PCB design software for high-speed projects involves identifying tools that can address the unique challenges posed by high-speed signals. Here are the key features to look for:

Advanced Simulation Tools

Importance: High-speed designs are susceptible to signal integrity and power integrity issues. Advanced simulation tools allow you to predict and mitigate these problems before physical prototyping. These simulation data can be pulled from 3rd party applications via direct integration, such as through Ansys CoDesigner for Altium Designer.

Examples: Simulations for signal behavior, impedance calculations, and power distribution network (PDN) analysis help ensure that your design will function as intended in real-world conditions.

 

 

PCB Stackup Management

Role: The stackup design is crucial for both signal and power integrity. A well-managed stackup ensures controlled impedance and minimizes signal distortion.

Features: Look for software that provides detailed stackup management capabilities, allowing you to define and optimize the layers of your PCB for high-speed signal integrity and power integrity. Additional design capabilities like HDI PCB stackup design are mandatory for today’s modern PCB designs.

 

 

Routing Tools

Necessity: Precise routing is essential for maintaining signal integrity in high-speed designs. Poor routing can lead to signal reflections and crosstalk.

Capabilities: Effective routing tools should offer features like differential pair routing, length tuning, and the ability to manage trace widths and clearances to ensure proper signal behavior.

 

 

Integration with Other Design Tools

Seamless Workflow: High-speed PCB design often requires the use of multiple tools, from schematic capture to simulation and layout.

Compatibility: Ensure that the PCB design software can integrate seamlessly with other tools in your design workflow, such as SPICE simulators, 3D modeling software, and thermal analysis tools. This integration streamlines the design process and reduces the likelihood of errors.

By focusing on these key features, you can select PCB design software that will help you address the challenges of high-speed PCB design and ensure a successful project outcome.

Evaluating PCB Design Software Options

When choosing PCB design software for high-speed projects, it is essential to evaluate various aspects to ensure the software meets your needs. Here are the critical factors to consider:

Performance and Reliability

• Speed and Accuracy of Simulations: High-speed designs require precise simulations to predict signal and power integrity issues. The software should offer fast and accurate simulation capabilities to streamline the design process and reduce the need for physical prototyping.
• Reliability: The software should be robust enough to handle complex designs without crashing or experiencing significant bugs. Reliability ensures that you can complete your design projects efficiently without unexpected interruptions.

User Interface and Usability

• Ease of Use: The software should have an intuitive user interface that allows designers to navigate and use its features effectively. A user-friendly interface reduces the learning curve and increases productivity.
• Learning Curve: Consider the time required to become proficient with the software. Software with extensive documentation, tutorials, and training resources can help new users get up to speed quickly.

Support and Community

• Customer Support: Access to responsive customer support is crucial, especially when dealing with complex high-speed designs. Ensure that the software provider offers reliable technical support to assist with any issues that may arise.
• Active User Community: An active user community can be a valuable resource for troubleshooting, tips, and best practices. Look for software with a vibrant community where users share their experiences and solutions.

Cost and Licensing

• Pricing Models: Evaluate the cost of the software, including any subscription fees or one-time purchase costs. Consider whether the pricing model aligns with your budget and project needs.
• Value for Money: Assess the features offered by the software relative to its cost. Ensure that the software provides good value for money by offering the necessary tools and capabilities for high-speed PCB design.

Selecting PCB Design Software: Options and Features

Selecting the right PCB design software is crucial for managing the complexities of high-speed PCB projects. Here is an overview of some leading software options and their features relevant to high-speed PCB design:

Altium Designer

Overview: Altium Designer is renowned for its comprehensive suite of tools that support all aspects of PCB design, from schematic capture to layout and simulation.

Features: It offers advanced signal integrity analysis, high-speed routing capabilities, and a robust stackup manager. Altium's unified design environment ensures seamless integration between different design stages, making it easier to manage high-speed projects.

 

 

Cadence Allegro

Overview: Cadence Allegro is a powerful PCB design tool favored for its high-performance capabilities and detailed design options.

Features: It excels in handling complex high-speed designs with features like comprehensive signal and power integrity analysis, advanced routing tools, and efficient stackup management. Cadence Allegro also integrates well with other Cadence design tools, providing a cohesive design workflow.

 

 

Siemens Xpedition

Overview: Siemens Xpedition is a versatile PCB design tool that caters to both simple and complex designs.

Features: Xpedition offers robust high-speed design capabilities, including signal integrity analysis, precise routing tools, and effective stackup management. It is known for its user-friendly interface and extensive support resources, making it a popular choice for many designers.

 

 

KiCad

Overview: KiCad is an open-source PCB design tool that has gained popularity for its flexibility and cost-effectiveness.

Features: While it may not have all the advanced features of commercial tools, KiCad provides essential high-speed design capabilities, including basic signal integrity checks and routing tools. It is an excellent option for designers looking for a budget-friendly solution without compromising on essential features.

 

 

Comparison of Features

• Signal Integrity Analysis: Altium Designer and Cadence Allegro offer the most comprehensive signal integrity analysis tools, essential for high-speed designs.
• Routing Tools: All four software options provide robust routing tools, but Cadence Allegro and Altium Designer stand out for their advanced capabilities.
• Stackup Management: Effective stackup management is crucial for high-speed designs, and Altium Designer and Cadence Allegro offer the most detailed and user-friendly tools in this area.
• Integration: Seamless integration with design tools from other vendors is a strong point for Altium Designer, ensuring a smooth design workflow. Cadence Allegro and Siemens Xpedition also offer direct integrations, but only with their own branded design applications. All other integrations rely on file exchanges.

Out of the above options, we most often recommend Altium Designer as it has become the industry-standard option for professional PCB designers. The talent pool for this tool is very broad, it is easy to learn, and we have deep expertise using this application. While not an open-source option like KiCad, it carries lower cost than Xpedition and Allegro yet offers more powerful design capabilities than you will find in those legacy applications. Therefore, when clients have not chosen a PCB design platform for their projects, we recommend selecting Altium Designer first.

Conclusion

Choosing the right PCB design software for high-speed projects is a critical decision that can significantly impact the success of your design. High-speed PCB design involves managing complex signal and power integrity issues, requiring advanced simulation tools, precise routing capabilities, and effective stackup management. The software you select should not only provide these features but also integrate seamlessly with other design tools to ensure a smooth workflow.

Ultimately, the best PCB design software for your high-speed PCB project will depend on your specific needs and constraints. By considering the key features and evaluating each option thoroughly, you can make an informed decision that will facilitate the successful completion of your high-speed PCB designs.

 

Whether you're designing high-speed PCBs for mil-aero embedded systems or a complex RF product, you should work with a design and development firm that can ensure your product will be reliable and manufacturable at scale. NWES helps aerospace OEMs, defense primes, and private companies in multiple industries design modern PCBs and create cutting-edge embedded technology, including power systems for high reliability applications and precision control systems. We've also partnered directly with EDA companies and advanced ITAR-compliant PCB manufacturers, and we'll make sure your design is fully manufacturable at scale. Contact NWES for a consultation.

 

---

---

---

---